Close Menu
Technology Mag

    Subscribe to Updates

    Get the latest creative news from FooBar about art, design and business.

    What's Hot

    This week’s best deal is a ‘kids’ Kindle Paperwhite that’s better than the adult version

    October 4, 2025

    Breaking up (Google) is hard to do

    October 4, 2025

    Ecovacs’ Deebot X8 and X9 Pro Omni robovacs have hit a new low price

    October 4, 2025
    Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram
    Subscribe
    Technology Mag
    Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram YouTube
    • Home
    • News
    • Business
    • Games
    • Gear
    • Reviews
    • Science
    • Security
    • Trending
    • Press Release
    Technology Mag
    Home » In the War Between Harassment and Censorship, No One Wins
    News

    In the War Between Harassment and Censorship, No One Wins

    News RoomBy News RoomSeptember 22, 20233 Mins Read
    Facebook Twitter Pinterest LinkedIn Reddit WhatsApp Email

    I don’t like to rank ethical issues in a hierarchy, but one problem sits with a weaver’s serenity at the center of a whole web of others: How do we ethically address networked harassment? Two recent articles about the ongoing battle to keep the stalking and harassment nexus of Kiwi Farms offline—one a Washington Post report detailing the saga, the other an unsigned statement from the Electronic Frontier Foundation (EFF)—perfectly illustrate the grinding gears of our age’s thorniest tech ethics issue.

    Kiwi Farms was subject to a broadly successful series of campaigns led by erstwhile targets of the site, like the streamer Clara Sorrenti and technologist Liz Fong-Jones. The activists—most of whom are trans women, a group the site has viciously harassed for years—pressured Tier 1 internet service providers (ISPs) like Cloudflare (sometimes known as the internet’s backbone) and got them to cut off Kiwi Farms, making it harder for the site to be accessed globally. The battle “raises serious doubts about society’s ability to block any site from the global web—even one that explicitly incites violence,” writes Washington Post reporter Nitasha Tiku.

    Meanwhile, the EFF, though condemning the site’s activities, criticized the campaign against it because the implications for speech, they say, are chilling. “We do not need more corporate speech police, however well-meaning,” they write.

    There are good reasons to be cautious about pressuring ISPs, but there are nuances to networked online harassment that ensure easy answers will elude us. In my taxonomy of online harassment, Kiwi Farms is an archetypal networked abuse campaign, with all three orders of harassment bearing down on a person. What makes it different from, say, Reddit and Twitter is the disproportionate amount of first-order harassment—abuse that intrudes physically on a target—that the site generates. Though especially vicious, it’s hardly unique in what it does. Exceptionally concentrated, perhaps, but not special. As with the 4chan message boards, GamerGate websites, Stormfront, 8chan, and 8kun, there is a playbook at work here.

    This means that, regardless of Kiwi Farms’ ultimate fate, the problem of such networked harassment will not go away. It’s a classic rights conflict, one that cannot be resolved either by unstinting adherence to abstract principles or by breezy exceptionalism. In every case, if the most devoted and prejudicial abusers can network their abuse, they leave democracy’s defenders with only the most unpalatable of choices. Let’s sail between Scylla and Charybdis for a while.

    The choice Kiwi Farms leaves us with is deeply unpalatable. Do we teach a corporation to indulge in censorship more overtly, eroding an already tenuous abstract principle that guards the open internet? Or do we rely on the state to protect us from online harassment, compelling them to encroach on speech with restrictions on physical freedom? Each path is a road to hell. One is lined with corporate PR speak, the other with police truncheons.

    EFF legal director Corynne McSherry pointed to the advantages of using a state institution to deal with these sorts of issues: documentation, accountability, and clear, common standards. She added that allies can help by “demanding that law enforcement do their jobs, which is not happening, and that Congress enact real and enforceable data privacy protections that would make doxxing harder,” and reminded me that the EFF’s focus here is global; many debates on this issue tend to be quite parochial, focused tightly on the US with occasional, glancing references to the EU.

    Share. Facebook Twitter Pinterest LinkedIn WhatsApp Reddit Email
    Previous ArticleI Failed Two Captcha Tests This Week. Am I Still Human?
    Next Article Why Tech Bros and Politicians Can’t Really Connect

    Related Posts

    This week’s best deal is a ‘kids’ Kindle Paperwhite that’s better than the adult version

    October 4, 2025

    Breaking up (Google) is hard to do

    October 4, 2025

    Ecovacs’ Deebot X8 and X9 Pro Omni robovacs have hit a new low price

    October 4, 2025

    Instagram wants me to make content — I just want to post a photo

    October 4, 2025

    Acer’s latest Spin 514 is so close to Chromebook greatness

    October 4, 2025

    Discord customer service data breach leaks user info and scanned photo IDs

    October 3, 2025
    Our Picks

    Breaking up (Google) is hard to do

    October 4, 2025

    Ecovacs’ Deebot X8 and X9 Pro Omni robovacs have hit a new low price

    October 4, 2025

    Instagram wants me to make content — I just want to post a photo

    October 4, 2025

    Acer’s latest Spin 514 is so close to Chromebook greatness

    October 4, 2025
    • Facebook
    • Twitter
    • Pinterest
    • Instagram
    • YouTube
    • Vimeo
    Don't Miss
    Science

    Coke Designed a Plastic Bottle to Sell the World More Soda

    By News RoomOctober 4, 2025

    Ivester was taking a gamble. Coca-Cola was ploughing tens of millions of dollars into modifying…

    Where Do Your Passwords Go When You Die?

    October 4, 2025

    Discord customer service data breach leaks user info and scanned photo IDs

    October 3, 2025

    Oregon’s National Guard lawsuit hinges on Trump’s Truth Social posts

    October 3, 2025
    Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram Pinterest
    • Privacy Policy
    • Terms of use
    • Advertise
    • Contact
    © 2025 Technology Mag. All Rights Reserved.

    Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.