Close Menu
Technology Mag

    Subscribe to Updates

    Get the latest creative news from FooBar about art, design and business.

    What's Hot

    The Fujifilm X-E5 is a simple, familiar, and impressive travel camera

    July 27, 2025

    CookUnity Cracked the Code on Meal Delivery By Using … Gasp … Chefs

    July 27, 2025

    The Verge’s 2025 back-to-school shopping guide

    July 27, 2025
    Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram
    Subscribe
    Technology Mag
    Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram YouTube
    • Home
    • News
    • Business
    • Games
    • Gear
    • Reviews
    • Science
    • Security
    • Trending
    • Press Release
    Technology Mag
    Home » Judge slams lawyers for ‘bogus AI-generated research’
    News

    Judge slams lawyers for ‘bogus AI-generated research’

    News RoomBy News RoomMay 13, 20252 Mins Read
    Facebook Twitter Pinterest LinkedIn Reddit WhatsApp Email

    A California judge slammed a pair of law firms for the undisclosed use of AI after he received a supplemental brief with “numerous false, inaccurate, and misleading legal citations and quotations.” In a ruling submitted last week, Judge Michael Wilner imposed $31,000 in sanctions against the law firms involved, saying “no reasonably competent attorney should out-source research and writing” to AI, as pointed out by law professors Eric Goldman and Blake Reid on Bluesky.

    “I read their brief, was persuaded (or at least intrigued) by the authorities that they cited, and looked up the decisions to learn more about them – only to find that they didn’t exist,” Judge Milner writes. “That’s scary. It almost led to the scarier outcome (from my perspective) of including those bogus materials in a judicial order.”

    As noted in the filing, a plaintiff’s legal representative for a civil lawsuit against State Farm used AI to generate an outline for a supplemental brief. However, this outline contained “bogus AI-generated research” when it was sent to a separate law firm, K&L Gates, which added the information to a brief. “No attorney or staff member at either firm apparently cite-checked or otherwise reviewed that research before filing the brief,” Judge Milner writes.

    When Judge Milner reviewed the brief, he found that “at least two of the authorities cited do not exist at all.” After asking K&L Gates for clarification, the firm resubmitted the brief, which Judge Milner said contained “considerably more made-up citations and quotations beyond the two initial errors.” He then issued an Order to Show Cause, resulting in lawyers giving sworn statements that confirm the use of AI. The lawyer who created the outline admitted to using Google Gemini, as well as the AI legal research tools in Westlaw Precision with CoCounsel.

    This isn’t the first time lawyers have been caught using AI in the courtroom. Former Trump lawyer Michael Cohen cited made-up court cases in a legal document after mistaking Google Gemini, then called Bard, as “a super-charged search engine” rather than an AI chatbot. A judge also found that lawyers suing a Colombian airline included a slew of phony cases generated by ChatGPT in their brief.

    “The initial, undisclosed use of AI products to generate the first draft of the brief was flat-out wrong,” Judge Milner writes. “And sending that material to other lawyers without disclosing its sketchy AI origins realistically put those professionals in harm’s way.”

    Share. Facebook Twitter Pinterest LinkedIn WhatsApp Reddit Email
    Previous ArticleYou can now preorder the wireless GameCube controller for Switch 2
    Next Article DJI said Mavic 4 Pro wouldn’t launch in US but these stores are selling it anyhow

    Related Posts

    The Fujifilm X-E5 is a simple, familiar, and impressive travel camera

    July 27, 2025

    The Verge’s 2025 back-to-school shopping guide

    July 27, 2025

    Apple beta season is here

    July 27, 2025

    Here are the laptops I’d tell any parent to consider for their back-to-school student

    July 26, 2025

    OnePlus Nord 5 review: selfie-centric midranger

    July 26, 2025

    Pebble is officially Pebble again

    July 25, 2025
    Our Picks

    CookUnity Cracked the Code on Meal Delivery By Using … Gasp … Chefs

    July 27, 2025

    The Verge’s 2025 back-to-school shopping guide

    July 27, 2025

    Razer’s Pro Click V2 Vertical Is the Ergonomic Gaming Mouse You’re Looking For

    July 27, 2025

    Apple beta season is here

    July 27, 2025
    • Facebook
    • Twitter
    • Pinterest
    • Instagram
    • YouTube
    • Vimeo
    Don't Miss
    Science

    The ICJ Rules That Failing to Combat Climate Change Could Violate International Law

    By News RoomJuly 27, 2025

    If a country fails to take decisive action to protect the planet from climate change,…

    Nemo’s Updated Dagger Osmo Tent Has Nicer Fabric and Better Design Details

    July 26, 2025

    Here are the laptops I’d tell any parent to consider for their back-to-school student

    July 26, 2025

    Do You Need a Barbecue Knife?

    July 26, 2025
    Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram Pinterest
    • Privacy Policy
    • Terms of use
    • Advertise
    • Contact
    © 2025 Technology Mag. All Rights Reserved.

    Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.